Skip past the menu

Review guidelines

Reviewers and businesses alike are held to these rules. In short: tell your own story, give details, and stay fair.

What a useful review contains

  • First-hand. You dealt with this business yourself, whether you bought, booked, hired or only asked for a quote, and not too long ago: roughly within the past few years.
  • Concrete. Say what you bought or what work was done, whether the price stayed where it was quoted, whether things arrived or finished on schedule, and how any problem was dealt with. Facts like these tell the next customer more than words of praise or complaint.
  • Even-handed. Stick to events and to how you were treated. Strong views are fine; personal attacks are not.
  • Within the limits. No shorter than 40 characters and no longer than 3,000.

Reviews we decline

The following are declined:

  • Anything written by a person employed by, related to or paid by the business, or by one of its competitors.
  • Anything written to earn a reward of whatever sort: cash, a present, a price cut, a raffle entry.
  • Reviews aimed at the wrong target: another company, or a maker, marketplace seller or payment service instead of the business being reviewed.
  • A second review of the same business by the same person inside 30 days.
  • Web addresses, telephone numbers, email addresses, or an employee’s full name or contact information.
  • Threats, harassment and hate speech, profanity hurled at individuals, or anything sexual.
  • Text lifted from somewhere else, or produced with AI tools instead of recounting your own experience.
  • Claims that someone committed a crime. Those belong with the police or other authorities, though you may still set out what happened to you.

Off-limits for businesses

Asking every customer for a review is encouraged. What a business may not do:

  • Reward a review in any way, or reward only the favorable ones.
  • Seek reviews from happy customers alone, or talk unhappy ones out of leaving one.
  • Review itself or a rival, whether directly or through employees, relatives or agencies.
  • Lean on or threaten a reviewer to get a review altered or withdrawn.

Behind this list stands a federal rule: the US Federal Trade Commission’s rule on consumer reviews, 16 CFR Part 465. A review obtained by breaching it does not stay up.

Appealing a decision

Each review submitted on The Opinion Atlas is read by a moderator before publication, and every rejection is recorded with its reason. To challenge a decision, write to us with the name of the company and the email address you reviewed under, and we will take a second look.