Before a review goes live
Nothing written on The Opinion Atlas goes live straight away.
- A new review is held as pending.
- A moderator compares it with the review guidelines and decides: publish or reject.
- Only once published does it appear on the company’s page and count in its score.
Along the way, four checks apply:
- That it recounts the writer’s own dealings with that company: an order, a booking, a visit or a quote.
- That it is free of web addresses, telephone numbers, private information about employees, threats and hateful language. Anything of that kind is cut.
- Whether one person is posting again and again, and whether the company’s staff or its competitors wrote it.
- That the same reviewer has not already reviewed that company in the past 30 days. The limit is one review per company every 30 days.
A business can reply in public to any review. It cannot edit, hide or delete one, and no payment changes the way a review is handled. Critical reviews pass through exactly the same process as favorable ones.
Computing a score
To get a company’s score, take the star ratings of its published reviews, average them, and round to one decimal place. There is no estimating, no weighting by payment and no manual adjustment.
Color coding waits until a company has 5 published reviews. Until then the number still appears, in gray and labeled Provisional, since a few reviews can tilt the result either way.
| Word shown | Average | As it appears |
|---|---|---|
| Exemplary | 4.5 – 5.0 | 4.7 |
| Strong | 4.0 – 4.4 | 4.2 |
| Middling | 3.0 – 3.9 | 3.4 |
| Weak | 2.0 – 2.9 | 2.5 |
| Very weak | under 2.0 | 1.6 |
Sales side, service side
Each reviewer tells us what kind of dealing it was: a purchase, a quote or a question, or a service. A shop that sells well can still repair badly, so once enough of those answers are in, the page shows the sales side and the service side as two separate scores.
The four details and the price questions
Reviewers may also score four details (openness & contact, fair on price, ease & turnaround, outcome) and answer two questions about price: “Did the quote hold when it came time to pay?” and “Did any charges turn up unannounced?” None of these figures is shown until 5 customers have answered.
Ordering a list by rating
When a list is sorted by rating, the number of reviews counts too: a company with three five-star reviews should not sit above one with forty strong ones. So each company’s place starts as if it had 5 reviews of 3.5 stars, and every real review moves it toward the company’s actual average:
rank value = (sum of all stars + 3.5 × 5) ÷ (number of reviews + 5)
This figure never appears on a page; it only decides order. What a company’s own page shows is always the straight average described above.
Review sources
Every review is labeled with its origin.
| Origin label | What it means |
|---|---|
| Added by the customer on The Opinion Atlas | Typed into our own review form by the customer. |
| Reached us via the business's own customer feedback form | The business gathered it from its own customers and passed it on to us. Feedback the business picked out, edited or paid for is never accepted. |
| Reviews from other review sites | Posted first by the customer on a different review platform, and carried over as it was published there. |
How a listing is built
A listing begins with facts about the business that we collect and check: its name, street address, phone number and website. Should the business close, or should we become unable to confirm those facts, we take the listing out of view instead of erasing it, and every review on it stays intact.
Claiming a listing is free for the company concerned. It can then fix any of those details and reply to reviews, while its score stays exactly as it was.
Reporting a problem
Under each review is a Report a problem link. Use it when a review:
- breaks the review guidelines,
- describes a different company, or
- does not seem genuine to you.
A moderator examines every report, then removes the review, leaves it up, or asks its author for more information. While that check is under way, the review stays visible.